New Prognostic Tool Helps Leukemia Patients Plan for Cancer Treatment
First validated prognostic score offers valuable insights for patients advised to ‘watch and wait’
(WASHINGTON, April 8, 2020) — A new prognostic tool predicts how long someone diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) will be able to wait before starting cancer treatment. Researchers describe what they hope will become a point-of-care resource to help improve clinical decision making in a study published today in the journal Blood.
The tool, which is based on the results from three common and widely available tests, could help alleviate the frustration patients feel when told that they have cancer but should ‘watch and wait’ rather than starting treatment immediately – the strategy medical guidelines recommend for patients with early-stage CLL who don’t have disease symptoms. Such patients comprise about 70-80% of those diagnosed with CLL each year. It is estimated that more than 400,000 patients in the United States and Europe currently fall into this category.
In addition to offering patients a better sense of how they might need to adjust work, travel, and other activities to plan for cancer treatment, the prognostic tool can help doctors determine how frequently to monitor each patient. Most existing prognostic tools for CLL focus on assessing a patient’s chance of survival once the disease has progressed to the point that treatment is necessary. The new tool, called IPS-E, is the first validated prognostic score specifically tailored to forecast the need for treatment.
“While some patients display a milder disease never requiring therapy, others present active disease shortly after diagnosis and require intervention,” said lead study author Davide Rossi, MD, Institute of Oncology Research in Bellinzona, Switzerland. “The IPS-E is a simple and a robust prognostic tool based on routine clinical and laboratory variables. The simplicity of IPS-E should facilitate its translation to the clinic.”
CLL is a cancer of the white blood cells that causes the body to produce too many lymphocytes, a type of immune cell. The disease typically progresses more slowly than other forms of leukemia and many patients have no symptoms. As CLL gets worse, it can cause fatigue, swollen lymph nodes and frequent infections and increase the risk of other types of cancer and immune system problems.
Previous studies have shown there is no survival benefit to starting available therapies until a patient’s white blood cell counts and symptoms reach a certain threshold. Among all CLL patients, roughly one-third never require treatment, a third will need treatment only after many years without symptoms, and a third require therapy within the first few months or years. However, until now doctors have lacked evidence-based tools for predicting which patients will fall into which category, said Dr. Rossi. Most patients are advised to visit their doctor every 3-12 months to check for signs of disease progression.
This research drew data from 4,933 patients with asymptomatic early-stage CLL who had participated in 11 international cohort studies. Starting with a training cohort of 333 patients, researchers found that three factors consistently and independently correlated with a shorter time to first treatment: unmutated immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region (IGHV) genes, high absolute lymphocyte counts, and palpable lymph nodes.
They used this information to develop a prognostic score with each factor counting as one point. Patients with zero factors are considered to have a low risk of needing treatment within five years of their diagnosis. Patients with one factor are considered to face an intermediate risk and patients with two or three factors are considered high risk.
Validating the scoring system using data from 10 other cohorts, the researchers found that about 30% of patients were categorized as low risk, 35% were at intermediate risk and 35% were at high risk. The scores correlated closely with actual outcomes; of those in the low-risk category, 8.4% required treatment within five years, compared to 28.4% in the intermediate group and 61.2% in the high-risk group.
The three tests required to establish a patient’s prognostic score are widely available. Lymphocyte counts and lymph node status are already assessed as part of routine CLL diagnosis. The genetic test to determine IGHV status is typically performed when a patient is preparing to start treatment. Performing this test at the time of diagnosis would allow doctors and patients to benefit from the prognostic tool and the test would not need to be repeated later if the patient begins treatment.
In addition to its importance for patients and doctors, the prognostic tool can also inform the design of clinical trials, for example to assess monitoring and early intervention strategies for patients who face the highest risk of disease progression.
“The IPS-E can be regarded as a building block to which newly discovered independent outcome predictors for patients with early stage CLL could be added,” said Dr. Rossi. “A prospective study would help to further assess and eventually strengthen this prognostic tool.”
Blood (www.bloodjournal.org), the most cited peer-reviewed publication in the field of hematology, is available weekly in print and online. Blood is a journal of the American Society of Hematology (ASH) (www.hematology.org).
Leah Enser, American Society of Hematology